Elevance, Cigna And CVS Rule Over Self-Insured Plan Administration, Researchers Find

Self-insured health plans dominate the U.S. employer plan market, and three big health insurers — Elevance, Cigna and CVS Health — dominate the market for administrative services for those self-insured plans.

Jean Abraham, Amanda Cook and E. Tice Sirmans have published data supporting those conclusions in a paper on the “administrative-services only” market in Health Affairs, an academic journal that focuses on topics related to paying and delivering health care services.

The researchers argued that understanding the self-insured employer plan market and the ASO contractor market is critical for any researchers who want to understand the U.S. commercial health insurance market, because about 65% of the U.S. workers with employer-sponsored health coverage are in self-insured health plans.

Over the period from 2010 through 2022, the employer plan market attracted 130 to 187 providers of fully insured group coverage each year and 53 to 62 ASO contractors, according to the researchers’ analysis of data reported to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners and compiled and distributed by S&P Capital IQ Pro.

Elevance, Cigna and CVS were administering coverage for about 71 million of the participants in the self-insured plans by 2022.

ASO fees averaged about $190 per enrollee at the “top 3 ASOs” and $258 per enrollee at the other ASO, and the median profit for all players was $40 per enrollee per year, the researchers found.

But the top 3 ASOs always reported profits, ranging from about $9 to $68 per enrollee per year, and the median result from the other ASOs was a loss of about $13 per enrollee per year.

“This statistic suggests that many insurers in this group were incurring ASO business losses, which may reflect unanticipated expenses or strategic pricing decisions (for example, pricing to acquire volume for provider negotiations),” the researchers write.

The researchers suggest that self-insured plans may be paying higher prices for health care than other payers.

One way for the NAIC to help researchers and employers get more information about the ASO market would be to require insurers to break information about their ASO operations down by state, the researchers suggest.

The researchers’ paper is part of a Health Affairs issue focusing on risk adjustment, insurance markets and related topics.

Also in the issue:

 

Source Link

Recommended Articles

State PBM laws Face ERISA Preemption Challenges in Court

States seeking to limit the power of pharmacy benefit managers are running into legal roadblocks. Every state, as well as the federal government, has enacted PBM legislation over the last decade to rein in an industry accused of anticompetitive business practices. Those efforts have seen mixed results as agencies struggle to enforce requirements and courts ...

Read More

Employer Health Cost Crunch Is Worse Than Projected

There’s new evidence that double-digit health cost increases were hitting employers well before the forecasts of big spikes for 2027 — forcing big changes in workplace coverage for millions of Americans. Why it matters: The findings offer a higher-resolution view of how much health spending is putting a drag on the labor market and increasing ...

Read More

HHS Finalizes Changes To HIPAA Privacy Rule

HHS' Office for Civil Rights finalized a HIPAA privacy rule change cutting the protected health information request response window to 15 calendar days. The final regulation clarifies individuals can retrieve electronic PHI through health apps when entities can support that format.

Read More

Sutter Health-Allina Health Deal Clears Key Hurdle

Sutter Health and Allina Health have achieved a milestone in their plan to merge. The health systems agreed to invest $2.15 billion as part of a 10-year oversight arrangement that Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison (D) announced Monday. The deal has been under state review for months. Under terms of the agreement, Sacramento, California-based Sutter ...

Read More
arrowcaret-downclosefacebook-squarehamburgerinstagram-squarelinkedin-squarepauseplaytwitter-squareyoutube-square