State PBM laws Face ERISA Preemption Challenges in Court

States seeking to limit the power of pharmacy benefit managers are running into legal roadblocks.

Every state, as well as the federal government, has enacted PBM legislation over the last decade to rein in an industry accused of anticompetitive business practices. Those efforts have seen mixed results as agencies struggle to enforce requirements and courts strike down new policies.

PBMs are fighting back by lobbying government officials and challenging bills in the courtroom.

In the judiciary, PBMs have often relied on the argument that the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, or ERISA, preempts state laws when it comes to employer-sponsored health insurance and other large group health plans.

Here’s how PBMs bringing ERISA challenges against states are faring.

State victories

In 2020, the Supreme Court ruled against a lawsuit from the Pharmaceutical Care Management Association, which represents PBMs such as CVS Caremark parent company CVS Health, UnitedHealth Group unit Optum Rx and Cigna Group division Express Scripts. The high court upheld an Arkansas law mandating that PBMs link reimbursement to pharmacies’ drug acquisition costs, ruling it did not violate ERISA.

Since that decision, states have gone “gangbusters” in passing broader laws to regulate the sector, said Theresa Carnegie, an attorney at the law firm Mintz. Carnegie represents PBMs and health plans in pharmacy benefit cases.

States have generally been successful at defending provisions that regulate pricing issues, such as pharmacy reimbursement.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit in 2022 ruled against the Pharmaceutical Care Management Association and allowed a North Dakota law that limits the fees and copayments PBMs charge.

In August, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit affirmed Arkansas’ right to force PBMs to submit data about their compensation and to pay dispensing fees to pharmacies. The court sided against Central States, Southeast and Southwest Areas Health and Welfare Fund, a multiemployer welfare benefit plan covering about 500,000 members that’s also known as TeamCare.

PBMs score wins

PBMs have been able to stall other laws or specific provisions, partly by arguing for ERISA preemption, including statutes focused on network adequacy and plan or benefit design.

“Any willing provider” mandates requiring PBMs to accept pharmacies into their networks and so-called anti-steering provisions that bar PBMs from directing members to pharmacies their parent companies own have not held up in court, said A.J. Barbarito, senior associate at law firm Frier Levitt who represents pharmacies.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit found Oklahoma’s 2019 law forcing PBMs to modify how they establish pharmacy networks violated federal law, agreeing with the Pharmaceutical Care Management Association, which initiated the suit. The Supreme Court declined to hear the case last year.

The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Iowa last year delivered preliminary injunctions in three separate cases blocking network restrictions. The Iowa Association of Business and Industry, Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Iowa and Optum Rx are the plaintiffs.

In August, the U.S. District Court for the Central District of Illinois issued a preliminary injunction that paused annual reporting obligations enacted last year. The Pharmaceutical Care Management Association is the plaintiff in the case.

Results of other legal actions are pending. The Pharmaceutical Care Management Association filed an amended complaint against California Attorney General Rob Bonta (D) in July. The trade group claims the state’s 2025 law requiring PBMs to act as a fiduciary to their clients conflicts with ERISA.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit heard oral arguments in September in a case challenging a 2025 ruling for Express Scripts in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Arkansas. The lower court didn’t accept the ERISA preemption argument, but ruled the statute likely discriminates against out-of-state pharmacies.

The Pharmaceutical Care Management Association and CVS Health filed lawsuits in May with comparable allegations over a similar Tennessee law.

What’s next?

States are forging ahead with new laws despite the legal wrangling.

Arizona, Oklahoma and other states are also considering laws to break up vertically integrated companies that include PBMs and pharmacies. At the national level, legislators from both parties support bills to split up these types of companies.

“If there’s not some breathing room made here within ERISA and health plan regulation, it seems there may be some bipartisan appetite for actually breaking these companies up,” Barbarito said.

States will also continue to enforce laws already on the books. Florida Commissioner of Insurance Regulation Michael Yaworsky collectively fined 13 PBMs nearly $13 million for violating state law this month, for example.

 

Source Link 

Recommended Articles

HHS Finalizes Changes To HIPAA Privacy Rule

HHS' Office for Civil Rights finalized a HIPAA privacy rule change cutting the protected health information request response window to 15 calendar days. The final regulation clarifies individuals can retrieve electronic PHI through health apps when entities can support that format.

Read More

Sutter Health-Allina Health Deal Clears Key Hurdle

Sutter Health and Allina Health have achieved a milestone in their plan to merge. The health systems agreed to invest $2.15 billion as part of a 10-year oversight arrangement that Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison (D) announced Monday. The deal has been under state review for months. Under terms of the agreement, Sacramento, California-based Sutter ...

Read More

CMS Targets $90B In Savings With Sweeping New Anti-Fraud Rule

CMS is targeting nearly $90 billion in federal savings over the next decade under a sweeping newly proposed anti-fraud rule that would reach across Medicare, Medicaid and the ACA marketplace. The rule, proposed Nov. 16 and titled Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare (CRUSH), would tighten provider enrollment screening, expand fraud reporting requirements for Medicare ...

Read More

CMS Distributes $10B To Strengthen Rural Health Care Access

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services will distribute $10 billion among all 50 states during the second year of the Rural Health Transformation Program. This funding is intended to build on early progress and deliver lasting improvements in access, quality and health outcomes for rural Americans. “President Trump made a historic investment in rural ...

Read More
arrowcaret-downclosefacebook-squarehamburgerinstagram-squarelinkedin-squarepauseplaytwitter-squareyoutube-square