US Supreme Court Rejects Challenge To $2.7 Bln Blue Cross Settlement

The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear a challenge to a $2.7 billion nationwide class action settlement with Blue Cross Blue Shield over allegations that the insurance giant overcharged commercial and individual subscribers for years.

The justices without comment denied a petition from home improvement retailer Home Depot objecting to the landmark antitrust settlement. The court also declined to hear a related challenge to a $667 million fee award for the class attorneys who negotiated the deal.

The fee amount, which a lower court judge approved, would be among the largest-ever class action attorney awards.

Health insurance subscribers in the decade-long case accused Blue Cross Blue Shield Association and others of unlawfully agreeing not to compete with one another, leading to higher insurance costs. Blue Cross denied any wrongdoing in agreeing to settle the case in 2020.

Home Depot did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Blue Cross in a statement on Monday said it welcomed the justices’ rulings “and the opportunity to begin to implement this settlement.”

Boies, Schiller & Flexner chairman David Boies, one of the lead class attorneys, in a statement on Monday called the Supreme Court’s orders “a great result for consumers and the entire health insurance system.”

Boies said “consumers will now receive the billions of dollars of refunds they are due and injunctive relief that will bring increased competition throughout the United States.”

Attorneys from law firms Hausfeld and Cooper & Kirk also represent the subscriber class.

Both Supreme Court petitions challenged an order last year by the Atlanta-based 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that upheld the settlement.

Home Depot objected to the accord on the grounds that it would restrict future antitrust claims against Blue Cross. The fee objection claimed the amount should be no more than $194 million, based on multiplying the number of hours the lawyers said they worked by a prevailing hourly rate.

 

 

Source Link

Recommended Articles

State PBM laws Face ERISA Preemption Challenges in Court

States seeking to limit the power of pharmacy benefit managers are running into legal roadblocks. Every state, as well as the federal government, has enacted PBM legislation over the last decade to rein in an industry accused of anticompetitive business practices. Those efforts have seen mixed results as agencies struggle to enforce requirements and courts ...

Read More

Employer Health Cost Crunch Is Worse Than Projected

There’s new evidence that double-digit health cost increases were hitting employers well before the forecasts of big spikes for 2027 — forcing big changes in workplace coverage for millions of Americans. Why it matters: The findings offer a higher-resolution view of how much health spending is putting a drag on the labor market and increasing ...

Read More

HHS Finalizes Changes To HIPAA Privacy Rule

HHS' Office for Civil Rights finalized a HIPAA privacy rule change cutting the protected health information request response window to 15 calendar days. The final regulation clarifies individuals can retrieve electronic PHI through health apps when entities can support that format.

Read More

Sutter Health-Allina Health Deal Clears Key Hurdle

Sutter Health and Allina Health have achieved a milestone in their plan to merge. The health systems agreed to invest $2.15 billion as part of a 10-year oversight arrangement that Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison (D) announced Monday. The deal has been under state review for months. Under terms of the agreement, Sacramento, California-based Sutter ...

Read More
arrowcaret-downclosefacebook-squarehamburgerinstagram-squarelinkedin-squarepauseplaytwitter-squareyoutube-square